Skip to content

Case study · Approvals · After hours · Ontario

Every repair waits for one person's OK

Published

Short answer

When one person approves every repair and the office sorts every call, text and email by hand, small jobs take three to five hours a day and night emergencies end with waking the boss.

This is one of three conversations we had in November with landlords and property managers about maintenance. We've left out names and anything that would identify them. The words in quotes are theirs.

Who they are

A family-run property management company in Ontario looking after about 200 units. The owner makes the money decisions. A small office team takes the calls, and in-house maintenance staff do most of the work. Outside contractors come in when the team is swamped.

How a repair request travels today

Requests arrive every way at once: phone calls, texts and emails to the office, and sometimes a tenant who catches someone in the hallway. The office writes it down, checks with the owner, then sends in-house staff or, in their words, they "phone a guy."

Most of it is small. Something like a smoke alarm battery comes up "eight to 10 times in a day, or less, or some days more." Sorting it all takes the office "about 3-4 hours? It could be 3-5," every day.

Where it breaks

Every cost goes through one person. "It's up to [the owner] to decide the cost of repairs." That keeps spending under control, but it also means every repair with a price on it waits until the owner can be reached, and the office spends its day relaying.

Nights have only two settings. One of the team described the after-hours rule plainly: "If somebody calls me at 2 o'clock in the morning, I'll tell them I apologize, but you'll have to wait till the morning… if it's like a disaster, well, then it's kind of wake up the boss." And when it really is urgent: "if it's an emergency, emergency, I will have to show up."

Nothing in between tells a dripping tap from a burst pipe before someone's phone rings.

Maintenance calls land on the wrong desk. Part of the team handles sales and leasing, and repair calls still find them: "he shouldn't get those calls if that could be done by some sort of automated system." They were equally clear about the limit. Sales calls stay with a person, and nobody wants software interfering there.

The same repair is recorded twice. When an outside vendor is paid quickly, say by e-transfer after an emergency, the payment goes into a spreadsheet and then again into the property management software. "It's cumbersome, but I catch an awful lot of it that way." And: "it seems a lot of redundant work."

What it costs

Three to five hours a day of one person's time goes to sorting requests rather than fixing anything. The owner is the bottleneck for every priced repair and the last line of defence at night. And the paper trail exists, but in two places that have to be reconciled by hand.

What would change it

The team didn't ask for a new property management system. They asked for the maintenance calls to stop landing on people who shouldn't have to sort them, while the people who need to decide still decide.

How Mendalot handles it

Tenants write in from the number they already have, or a link emailed to them, with no app to install. Each request becomes one maintenance ticket with the follow-up questions already asked, so the office reads a complete ticket instead of writing one.

Small jobs that can wait are triaged and queued for the morning. A real emergency pages the on-call person with the property's shut-offs and steps, so "wake up the boss" happens only when it should.

The owner sets a spend limit once. Any quote over it is held until a person approves it, and anything under it can go ahead without a phone call. Every message, approval and visit is in one record, which is the record the team needs when they reconcile a payment or a tenant disputes a repair.

General information, not legal, financial or professional advice.

  • Case study · Ontario

    The 2 a.m. call nobody on the team can decide

    A property manager with owner clients on after-hours maintenance today: an answering service that can't troubleshoot, and vendors who call mid-job for the OK.

  • Case study · Ontario

    When the maintenance line is your own cell

    An owner-operator with about 40 units on doing repairs himself: tenants who text his cell, long drives to every job, and no record when a repair is disputed.