Case study · After hours · Approvals · Ontario
The 2 a.m. call nobody on the team can decide
Published
Short answer
The answering service takes the call but can't judge the problem or approve the work, so every night call still ends with someone on the team, or a vendor waiting on site for permission.
This is one of three conversations we had in November with landlords and property managers about maintenance. We've left out names and anything that would identify them. The words in quotes are theirs.
Who they are
A lean property management team in Ontario that manages buildings for several owners, whom they call clients. Two maintenance staff share an on-call week. During the day, tenants are pointed to the tenant portal in the team's property management software.
How a night call works today
A tenant calls the main number and presses zero. That reaches an after-hours answering service, which follows the team's script and a sheet that says who to call for each unit. The service either sends a vendor or calls whoever is on call that week.
The on-call person gets two to four of those calls a week, "a little more because winter's coming." The service costs about $200 a month, plus a per-minute fee.
The manager is clear about what the service can and can't do: "These aren't plumbers. These aren't maintenance people… so we don't have high expectations." Tenants, meanwhile, will say whatever it takes "to get someone out there," so the person on call can't trust the first description either.
Where it breaks
Nobody on the call can make the decision. "After hours is where decisions get made without the normal chain of command." The answering service can't judge whether a leak can wait until morning, so it either wakes someone or sends a vendor, and both cost money.
Vendors stop and call for permission. One weekend, a plumber on site called to ask whether he could cut into the drywall. The manager's answer says it all: "I'm not there, I'm not a plumber, you tell me." The job stalls while two people who can't see the problem try to agree on it.
Every owner has a different limit. The team's approval limit is $300, and it's moving to about $500, because "$300 gets you nothing these days." But it also "depends on which client's calling." Some owners have their own preferred vendors. Any vendor from outside that list has to be insured and reputable. None of that is in front of the person answering the phone at night.
The vendor arrives without the details. "Where's the furnace?" When nobody can answer, "everybody's scared, our phones are blowing up." Later in the call it came up again: "Where is the shutoff? … where's the lockbox? … details that you need quickly at two in the morning."
Tenants won't use an app. "I don't picture tenants having [the portal] on their phone." The one number tenants already know is the one that matters.
What the manager wants
The goal fits in one sentence: "My ultimate goal is, I don't want anybody getting called at 2 in the morning."
That doesn't mean ignoring emergencies. It means the calls that reach a person should be the ones that need one, and the person should get them with everything needed to decide: what's wrong, what's been checked, what the owner allows, and where the shut-off is.
They also want to keep the number tenants already have, and the same process however a request comes in. They want the property details on every vendor ticket. And they want to decide for themselves whether tenants are told they're talking to software, because "people are divided."
How Mendalot handles this night
Mendalot takes the request from the number tenants already have, asks the follow-up questions an answering service can't, and decides whether it can wait until morning. A real emergency pages the on-call person with the property's shut-offs and steps. If nobody acknowledges within 15 minutes, it pages the next person on the rotation.
Each owner gets their own spend limit. When a vendor quotes over it, the quote is held until a person approves it, so the vendor knows to wait and the owner's rule is the one that applies. The vendor gets the property's brief with the job: where the shut-offs, the furnace and the lockbox are.
Every message, approval and visit lands in one record, so in the morning the team can see who did what, and when.
General information, not legal, financial or professional advice.